Sunday, July 16, 2006

The curious incident of the Pakistan.

Assumptions matter, whether in detective stories or securing the country.

One such assumption is that by and large Pakistani awaam is in favour of friendship with India, it is in favour of peace and would like nothing more than to move along, and it is only Pakistani Army which is against it.

This is interesting, in light of bombay blasts.

One wonders, if Paskitani public feels the way we are assured it does, why is Pakistani public silent? Why is there no reaction?

Ok, the last bit in not technically correct. There have been reactions,

1) Condemnation of the blasts.
2) Denial of Pakistani involvement
3) Kashmir.

1) doesn't matter much one way or other (I mean, what are they going to say? It was a good thing !)

2) is more interesting if Pakistan is not involved then something is amiss, I do not believe this however, that is I believe that there is involvement of state of Pakistan

3) ofcourse negates 1)

So if Pakistani public wants to be friend with India, why is there no reaction against Pakistani state? Why are they silent? Why don't they ask their government to stop the terrorism?
(With the possible exception of out-of-power and exiled politicians)

May be our assumption is incorrect then? May be Pakistani junta desire to move along and be friends with Indians is not strong enough to condemn and renounce resolution of disputes through extremely coercive and violent methods.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Gaurav,

How much influence has the Pakistani awam in the state of the nation?

Flying Machine said...

Or maybe just like the Indian junta they want to live their lives.

Gaurav said...

Its a dictatorial state. As with Hitler, 63% of the people were opposed to him and his policies when he was "elected" in the govt. But, when they realized that raising a voice against him costs you your life, people went along knowing his wrong-doings. I don't see Pakistan much different in terms of voice peace loving people have in Pakistan. Probably a failure of organizational skills on part of peace loving leaders.

froginthewell said...

But I guess the guys who make these assumptions will agree with the Pakistani awam on points 1 and 3; and keep quiet on point 2, which is no better than supporting it. Anyway excellent point, I agree with your analysis of Pakistani awams' psyche.

Anonymous said...

The recent murder of allama turabi in pakistan as well as the earlier blast in which 50 people among them Maulana Noorani was killed are commited by the sister organizations of the jehadis who act in India.

doubtinggaurav said...

Frog,

You are right and thanks.

Anon,

Yor are also right, I will call it blowback effect.

Anonymous said...

That's a great story. Waiting for more. pheonix car lcd display what+is+acyclovir curved camcorder

Anonymous said...

Excellent, love it! »